The Changing Face of R&D Tax Credits: New IRS Reporting Requirements, Emerging Opportunities, and th
Every day, heat treating companies invest considerable time, talent, and money developing better ways to process materials, improve metallurgical properties, reduce distortion, and meet increasingly demanding customer specifications. What many owners may not realize is that some of these efforts could also generate substantial federal and state Research and Development (R&D) tax credits.
Perhaps the biggest misconception about the R&D tax credit is that it is reserved for companies developing groundbreaking technologies or operating laboratories filled with scientists. In reality, qualifying research often takes place right on the production floor. Developing a new heat treatment cycle, experimenting with quenching methods, or finding solutions to difficult metallurgical challenges may involve the very activities the R&D tax credit was designed to encourage.
And here's something that often surprises business owners: research doesn't have to succeed to qualify. An unsuccessful experiment can be just as relevant as a successful one, provided the work meets the requirements of the tax law.
For many heat treating companies, the real question isn't whether they are conducting research. It's whether they are recognizing, documenting, and taking advantage of the research they are already performing.
Now, with significant changes to IRS reporting requirements beginning in 2026 and new opportunities emerging through artificial intelligence (AI), understanding the R&D tax credit is becoming more important than ever. However, the rules surrounding the federal R&D tax credit are changing. Beginning with the 2026 tax year for calendar-year taxpayers, new IRS reporting requirements will require many companies to provide considerably more detail about their qualifying research activities and the associated expenses.
At the same time, emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) are creating additional opportunities for heat treating companies to conduct qualifying research, particularly in areas involving process optimization, predictive modeling, and advanced manufacturing controls.
These developments present both opportunities and challenges. Understanding what qualifies for the R&D credit, how the new reporting requirements affect your company, and how to maintain practical, defensible documentation will be increasingly important.
New IRS Reporting Requirements: Form 6765, Section G
One of the most significant changes affecting companies claiming the federal R&D tax credit is the expansion of IRS Form 6765, Credit for Increasing Research Activities.
The revised form includes Section G, which requires more detailed reporting of the business components associated with qualified research expenditures.
Previously, companies generally reported their qualified research expenses in broad categories, including employee wages, supplies, and contract research. Although taxpayers were already required to maintain records supporting their research activities and expenses, they were not generally required to provide detailed business-component-level expense information directly on Form 6765.
For tax years beginning after December 31, 2025, Section G becomes mandatory for many taxpayers claiming the R&D credit.
What Does the IRS Mean by a "Business Component"?
One term heat treating companies will encounter frequently in the revised Form 6765 is business component. While this may sound like another complicated IRS term, the concept is fairly straightforward.
For most heat treating companies, a business component is simply a new or improved product or manufacturing process that the company is working to develop.
For example, experimenting with a new quenching method to reduce distortion may be developing an improved manufacturing process. Similarly, a company developing a new heat treatment cycle to achieve specific hardness or metallurgical properties may also be working on a qualifying business component.
The tax law also recognizes other types of business components, including software, techniques, formulas, and inventions.
In plain English, the IRS wants to know what you were trying to develop or improve and how much you spent doing it. That is really the heart of the new reporting requirement.
Rather than simply reporting that a company incurred $500,000 in qualified research expenses during the year, the IRS generally wants to know what the company was working to develop or improve and how much of those expenses relate to that work.
For heat treating companies, this means identifying the technical projects and process improvements that may qualify for the credit and connecting the associated employee wages, supplies, and outside research costs to those activities.
The underlying research requirements have not changed. What has changed is the level of detail many companies must now provide when reporting their qualified research expenses.
What Additional Information Must Be Reported?
Under the new requirements, companies subject to Section G must provide additional information about their qualifying business components, including:
- Identification and description of the business component associated with the research.
- Whether the business component involves a product, process, or another qualifying category.
- The information requested concerning the research activities and business-component classification.
- Qualified employee wages associated with conducting, directly supervising, and directly supporting research.
- Qualified supplies consumed during research.
- Eligible computer rental expenses and contract research expenditures.
For heat treating companies, a business component could be a newly developed carburizing process, an improved quenching method, or a heat treatment process designed to achieve specific metallurgical characteristics.
Which Companies Must Complete Section G?
Not every company claiming the R&D credit will be required to complete Section G.
Under the IRS instructions described here, companies generally are exempt if their total qualified research expenses are $1.5 million or less, their average annual gross receipts for the preceding three tax years are $50 million or less, and they claim the credit on an original return. The qualified research expense threshold is determined at the controlled-group level.
For companies required to complete Section G, the IRS generally requires detailed reporting of business components representing at least 80% of total qualified research expenses, subject to a maximum of 50 business components. Remaining business components may be reported in the aggregate.
For example, assume a heat treating company incurs $2 million in qualified research expenses across 20 different R&D projects. If five of those projects account for $1.6 million, or 80% of the company's total qualified research expenses, the company generally would be required to report those five business components individually. The remaining 15 projects, representing $400,000 in qualified expenses, could be reported together. This example assumes that each project represents a separate business component.
This approach allows companies to focus their detailed reporting on the projects representing the majority of their research expenditures rather than requiring them to separately report every project.
Importantly, these changes do not alter the fundamental requirements for qualifying research. Instead, they require affected taxpayers to provide additional information about the research activities and expenses underlying their credit calculations.
For heat treating companies, this makes identifying qualifying projects and maintaining accurate expense allocations increasingly important.
What Heat Treating Activities May Qualify for R&D Tax Credits?
One of the biggest misconceptions about the R&D tax credit is that a company must invent something entirely new to qualify.
Fortunately, the IRS does not require you to reinvent the wheel. Sometimes, figuring out how to make the wheel stronger, last longer, or perform better under difficult conditions is where the research begins.
For heat treating companies, qualifying research may involve improving an existing process, developing a new approach to a metallurgical challenge, or experimenting with different methods to achieve a desired result.
Of course, not every technical problem qualifies. The work must meet the requirements of Internal Revenue Code Section 41, including a permitted purpose, technological uncertainty, reliance on principles of the physical or biological sciences, engineering, or computer science, and a process of experimentation.
The heat treating industry presents numerous situations in which these requirements may be satisfied.
Examples of potentially qualifying activities include:
1. Developing or Improving Heat Treatment Cycles
Experimenting with heating temperatures, soak times, cooling rates, and other processing parameters to achieve improved hardness, strength, toughness, or other metallurgical properties.
2. Improving Quenching Processes
Developing new or improved quenching methods to reduce distortion, cracking, residual stresses, or inconsistent metallurgical properties.
3. Developing Case Hardening Processes
Experimenting with carburizing, carbonitriding, nitriding, and other surface treatment methods to achieve specific case depths, hardness profiles, or wear characteristics.
4. Processing New Materials and Alloys
Developing heat treatment processes for unfamiliar alloys, specialized materials, or components with challenging metallurgical requirements.
5. Reducing Distortion and Dimensional Changes
Experimenting with alternative heat treatment cycles, fixturing methods, or cooling processes to minimize dimensional changes and improve finished-part consistency.
6. Improving Furnace Atmosphere Controls
Developing improved methods of controlling furnace atmospheres to reduce oxidation, decarburization, or inconsistent metallurgical results.
7. Developing Automated Process Controls
Designing and testing new control systems that improve temperature uniformity, process repeatability, or metallurgical consistency.
8. Improving Energy Efficiency
Experimenting with alternative processing methods that reduce energy consumption while maintaining required material properties and product quality.
These examples are not automatically qualified research. Each activity must be evaluated against the statutory requirements, and routine production, ordinary quality control, and the application of established processes generally do not qualify.
However, the fact that experimentation takes place on the production floor rather than in a dedicated research laboratory does not necessarily disqualify the activity.
Artificial Intelligence: An Emerging R&D Opportunity for Heat Treaters
Artificial intelligence seems to be finding its way into just about everything these days, and the heat treating industry is no exception.
While AI gets plenty of attention for writing emails and answering questions, some of its more interesting applications are happening on manufacturing floors.
Heat treating companies are exploring how AI can help predict distortion, optimize furnace cycles, improve metallurgical consistency, reduce energy consumption, and identify equipment problems before they become expensive surprises.
Recognizing these opportunities, the Metal Treating Institute has established an AI Task Force to help members understand and responsibly implement AI technologies.
What may be less obvious is that some of the technical experimentation involved in developing these applications could also qualify for federal R&D tax credits.
Consider a company developing an AI-based system to predict distortion during quenching. Engineers and metallurgists may experiment with different algorithms, temperature profiles, material characteristics, and cooling parameters to develop and validate a reliable predictive model.
Similarly, a company developing an AI-enabled system to optimize furnace temperatures or predict hardness profiles may encounter technical uncertainties requiring experimentation, testing, and evaluation of alternative approaches.
Other potential qualifying AI-related activities include:
- Developing predictive models for metallurgical properties.
- Experimenting with machine-learning algorithms to optimize heating and cooling cycles.
- Developing intelligent furnace atmosphere control systems.
- Designing automated defect detection systems.
- Developing digital models or simulations to predict heat treatment outcomes.
- Experimenting with adaptive process controls that respond to real-time operating data.
Importantly, simply purchasing commercially available AI software or installing ChatGPT, Claude, or Grok, does not automatically qualify for the R&D credit.
However, developing or improving manufacturing processes through technical experimentation involving AI may qualify, even when the company is not developing an entirely new AI platform.
As AI becomes more integrated into heat treating operations, companies should consider whether their technology development activities create additional R&D tax credit opportunities.
What Expenses Can Heat Treating Companies Include?
Identifying qualifying activities is only part of calculating the R&D credit. Companies must also determine which expenses are attributable to those activities.
Qualified research expenses generally fall into several categories.
Employee Wages
Wages paid to employees conducting, directly supervising, or directly supporting qualified research may be eligible.
For heat treating companies, these employees may include metallurgists, process engineers, furnace operators, technicians, programmers, and certain production supervisors.
The determining factor is the employee's actual involvement in qualified research, not the employee's job title.
Supplies Used During Experimentation
Materials consumed or used during qualified research may qualify, subject to statutory limitations.
Examples may include test materials, sample components, quenching media, specialty gases, and other non-depreciable supplies used during experimental processing.
Contract Research
Payments to outside laboratories, metallurgical specialists, software developers, and other third parties performing qualified research may also be eligible.
Generally, 65% of qualifying contract research expenditures may be included in the R&D credit calculation, subject to applicable requirements.
Computer Rental Expenses
Certain costs associated with renting computer capacity for qualified research may also qualify. This can be particularly relevant to companies developing computational models or AI applications, although ordinary software subscriptions and cloud services are not automatically eligible.
For many heat treating companies, employee wages represent the largest component of qualified research expenses.
An important consideration is that research may involve employees throughout the organization, not just those working in engineering or technical departments.
Documentation: Do Not Let Perfect Become the Enemy of Good
With the new Form 6765 reporting requirements, documentation is becoming more important than ever. But before anyone starts designing a complicated new recordkeeping system, let me offer a little practical advice.
After more than 30 years working with businesses on tax matters, I have learned that there is no such thing as a perfect R&D tax credit study.
The goal is not to create a mountain of paperwork. The goal is to maintain reasonable, reliable records that demonstrate what your company was trying to accomplish, what technical challenges it encountered, how it worked to overcome those challenges, and what it spent in the process.
I have seen companies spend more time designing elaborate tracking systems than their employees will ever spend using them. A sophisticated system that nobody follows is not worth much.
A simple recordkeeping system that your employees actually use is far more valuable than a perfect system that collects dust.
For many companies, much of the necessary documentation may already exist. Furnace logs, production records, testing results, engineering notes, process sheets, emails, and records of experimental runs can all help establish what research was performed.
The challenge is often not creating entirely new records but identifying, organizing, and preserving the information the company already generates.
Companies should focus on a few practical steps:
- Identify new or improved products and processes being developed throughout the year.
- Document the technical challenges encountered and the experimentation performed to resolve them.
- Identify employees involved in the research and maintain reasonable support for their qualified research time.
- Track materials, testing costs, and outside research expenses associated with qualifying projects.
- Retain existing technical records that help demonstrate the research activities performed.
Of course, simple does not mean sloppy. The IRS still expects taxpayers to maintain records sufficient to substantiate their credits. Estimates and allocations need a reasonable, supportable basis, and records should be maintained as the work is performed whenever practical.
The bottom line is that your documentation process should support your business, not become another business you have to run.
Start with what you already have, identify the gaps, and make improvements your employees can realistically maintain. Over time, a good system can become a better one.
And remember, the IRS is not awarding extra credit for the prettiest spreadsheet.
Looking Ahead
Heat treating has always been an industry built on technical knowledge, experience, and finding better ways to get the job done.
The federal R&D tax credit recognizes that kind of innovation when it meets the requirements of the tax law. Whether your company is developing new heat treatment processes, improving existing methods, or experimenting with artificial intelligence, there may be qualifying research activities worth evaluating.
The new Form 6765 reporting requirements mean companies need to pay closer attention to identifying their research projects and documenting the associated expenses. But that does not mean you need to turn your operation into a paperwork factory.
Start by taking a closer look at the technical challenges your employees are solving. Make sure you are capturing reasonable documentation of the work being performed, and do not overlook the people on your production floor who may be contributing to qualified research.
After all, some of the best research does not happen in a laboratory. It happens when someone on the shop floor says, "There has got to be a better way to do this," and then sets out to find one.
And if that work qualifies for an R&D tax credit, all the better.
This article provided to MTI in Collaboration with Ron Antal, CPA, MST
About the Author
Ron Antal, CPA, MST, Founder and Managing Director of RCG Tax Partners, a specialty tax consulting firm based in Stow, Ohio, focusing on federal and state R&D tax credits, cost segregation, and other tax incentives. Ron has more than 30 years of experience in corporate tax consulting, including experience with PwC and Deloitte.
This article provides general tax information and is not intended as advice regarding any particular taxpayer's circumstances.